January 2008


Abusive behavior did not make it into the diagnostic criteria of mental health disorders, nor were its psychodynamic, cultural and social roots explored in depth. As a result of this deficient education and lacking awareness, most law enforcement officers, judges, counselors, guardians, and mediators are worryingly ignorant about the phenomenon…The blissfully ignorant mental health professionals are simply unaware of the “bad sides” of the abuser and make sure they remain oblivious to them. They look the other way, or pretend that the abuser’s behavior is normative, or turn a blind eye to his egregious conduct.” — Dr. Sam Vanknin, Conning the System

Link: http://samvak.tripod.com/abusefamily10.html getmyspaceicons.com

Title: Taken

Author: Kathleen George

Publisher: Delacorte Press (New York, New York: 2001)

Genre: Fiction, Mystery

Length: 309 pages

  

Marina Benedict is a woman who has lost her sense of self, and knows only the role of victimization she has played since she was a child—to be the rescuer, to gain love through compromise and self-sacrifice, to remain hidden. As a child, Marina grew up in a home that was terrorized by her abusive father. At the age of ten, Marina tried to stop the violence by intervening between her father’s fists to save her frightened family. Marina was able to secure a brief respite from the physical blows; however, she became the target of her mother’s emotional abuse. After Marina’s father died the legacy he has left remains a source of torment. Marina struggles to remain close with her family while knowing that much of their connection has eroded. The cycle of violence that had gripped Marina’s family in the past continues when Marina married Michael Benedict, an emotionally distant man whose feelings are guised in manipulation. For many years, Marina tolerates Michael’s violence towards her, and meekly submits to being under his control.

Even the way Michael bristled, the little bit he moved, as soon as she showed the soft underbelly of her sadness, spoke of violence in him…He had not struck her except for that once. But the books, papers, dishes, he had thrown, broken. He had been on the verge of striking her a million times. The threat of it was almost worse, given her family history, than if he’d hit her.” (page 3)

Slowly, things begin to change. Marina can no longer appease Michael, and grows tired of trying. Marina’s façade of goodness, of always doing right, of saving others is quickly cracking—but who is she, underneath?

  

            On the verge of divorce, Marina’s life is about to undergo complete transformation. Marina struggles to make the choice that will either change her life forever or maintain the cycle of violence that she has only known as “love”.

            He’d been thinking. He must tell her, slowly, over time, over the phone, and then in person, how he is changing. That Saturday morning, months ago, when he threw things toward her, not at her—just audio—and videotapes, but a few of them ruined, and Marina seeing all over again her father, her father’s temper—that was bad. How clearly he sees himself now, from outside, from her point of view, as if he stepped over to stand beside her and look dispassionately. His inability to apologize, the way he’s been struck in resistance, and his indirect way of solving things…He wants to admit to this terrible anger of his. He wants to be rid of it once and for all.” (p. 167-16 8)

Through the darkest streets of Pittsburgh, and the darkest places within herself, Marina seeks to put her violent history to rest, and recreate her sense of self while undertaking a remarkable but dangerous journey. Without warning, Marina is thrust onto this journey when she witnesses the kidnapping of an infant on the streets of Pittsburgh. Without thinking, Marina follows the kidnapper, in an effort to rescue the baby. In a brutal confrontation Marina will face the ultimate battle for survival.

 

           

            Taken is not a conventional mystery novel, its challenge lies beyond the kidnapping that generates obvious attention but delves deeper into human motivations. Kathleen George writes an insightful novel that explores the passions, the demons, the history and hopes that define the motivations of the novel’s various characters. The storyline of the kidnapping, itself, is very intense and compelling. While Taken begins with Marina’s story and then the kidnapping, it veers into the very different perspectives of the police detective following the kidnapping, the family of the baby and into the perverse, demented lives of the kidnappers. The common thread that connects these very different stories is Marina, who becomes so invested in trying to save the baby that she puts her life at risk. The additional insight into the lives of the characters, and the intricacy of how their paths connect creates an emotional undercurrent seething with suspense.

  

Marina provides an interesting dimension of suspense. I found myself enthralled by her fight to save the baby, and wondering what she would make of her life. Marina is a very believable character—emulating goodness but flawed within, she cannot live up to the expectations beaten into her. Marina’s act to save the baby shows strength and integrity in a way that is different from her actions in the past; there is a subtle maturity happening as the story develops. Marina’s response to the kidnapping, yet another act of violence, calls upon strength to be more than passive but to develop purpose and put it to action. There are were many traits to Marina that are common to abuse survivors such as feeling numb or unable to identify feelings, being able to intuit or sense danger before an event occurs, struggling with self-esteem and being enmeshed in repeating patterns of dysfunctional or abusive behavior and/or relationships. Another trait evident in Marina is that she felt drawn or pulled in to people (or objects) that represent security, acceptance and/or love. For a person who has been traumatized, the pull can be so strong, that the person (or object) that represents these things becomes synonymous with love, acceptance and security. In these types of situations, the love is magical and filled with fantasy or filled with special meanings that hold no value in the real world, the need for the object or person becomes all consuming and the ability to remain independent diminishes as attachment increases. Addiction, abuse, and illness all result from these types of relationships based on dependency and victimization rather than equality and mutual respect.

Under her chaotic armor she is delicate. She’s Joan of Arc, just trying to manage the voices.” (p. 290)

Taken does not provide answers, the explanations are simple and may provoke further questions but what I did like is that I felt privileged to gaze into a window revealing connections and relationships in life that are rarely seen. I highly recommend Taken. As a first novel, Kathleen George has done an outstanding job.

Event: Battered Women, Abused Children, and Child Custody: A National Crisis. Fifth Annual Conference.
Date: January 11-13, 2008
Location: Clarion Hotel and Conference Center, Albany New York
About: Battered Women, Abused Children & Child Custody: A National Crisis was established in 2003 by two mothers, Therese Hannah, Ph.D. (Chair) of Latham, NY, and Liliane Heller Miller (Vice-Chair) of Charlotte, NC. The goal of BAC is to raise awareness of the complex issues, and problems facing battered women in and out of family court. The BAC documents, through research and scholarly information, the human rights and legal violations that deny battered women due process in the family court system, and often put children at risk. Through a public forum, The Conference offers discussions, presentations and stories of survivors. “It is open to lay persons, and of special interest to advocates, social workers, psychologists, attorneys, judges, legal personnel, and others involved in the issue of battered women’s and abused children’s legal and civil rights violations by family courts, DSS, and other government systems.”
The Conference also offers healing and support for families struggling against the injustices of the family court system.
BAC is, “..a self-sustaining, grassroots phenomenon that is entirely the volunteer work product of it’s creators and presenters.   We have no paid staff, nor are we financially supported by or affiliated with any particular group, organization, gender-based ideology, or political agenda.”
Also on this site: “Children Taken by The Family Courts” Quilt
About the Quilt: Mothers who have lost physical custody of their children through family court or divorce proceedings are invited to create a quilt panel (or square) to commerate their child(ren). You do not have to attend The Conference to contribute to the quilt. Instructions for creating a quilt square and mailing them to the BAC project are included online at the above link.

Litigating Custody with Batterers
Web links related to family court proceedings, survival guide for family court (Link 2), domestic violence, support for survivors, related facts/information and advocacy for abused children.
For Consideration:

End abusers from getting custody: Online Petition (NOT affiliated with conference or BWAC).
http://www.petitiononline.com/endtrend/petition.html

Author:  Cheryl Barnes
Website:
A Parent’s Guide to the “System” is a free online article discussing a parent’s rights when a child is placed out of home by a government agency or a parent is involved in an investigation by a government agency. It includes basic information on court proceedings, the rights of a parent and how to exercise those rights and advice on how to protect your child from abuse while in state care.
Much of the advise presented  is useful in many areas of involved by government or court officials. For example, under the heading “Demand a Copy of the Search Warrant” this could apply to dealing with Child Protective Services as easily as communicating with a guardian ad litem (emphasis on the language, not the search warrant):”Don’t be intimidated. Keep a proper perspective of the situation; you are willing to cooperate within the law.  The law dictates that a search warrant is required before entering a private home.  Your position should be:

I do want to cooperate.

I do not want to ignore proper procedure.

Why would you want to circumvent clearly established laws and procedures? 

I found the advice in this article to be very helpful :)

___________________________________________

To be fair I am offering more info about Suzanne Shell. From what I have seen on the web, Suzanne Shell is a highly determined, and controversial, family advocate, author and attorney fighting for parent’s rights and speaking out against injustice in the system. If there is a balanced counter view, I will post a link. However, I am asking for respect in the position you take–personall attacks and obscenties will not be tolerated.
Suzanne, feel free to leave a statement or any info about yourself or American Family Advocacy Center if you like.

More Info on Suzanne Shell:

Profane Justice (Suzanne’s site offers information on Family Rights, Information on Training Seminars, Letter and Advice to Foster Children and much more..)
http://www.profane-justice.org

Wikipedia- Suzanne Shell
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzanne_Shell

“Children of the State” by Mark Stout and Gail M. Armstrong, for “Freedom Magazine”. An article about parents whose rights were violated by the corruption of the (family services/human services, CPS) system that traumatizes children by unfairly taking them out of homes, with commentary by Suzanne Shell.
http://www.freedommag.org/english/vol32I1/page02.htm